Remember, you did not have to be present on 9/11 and you did not have to be a First Responder to be eligible. The benefits of the Victim Compensation Fund (VCF) and the World Trade Center Health Program (WTCHP) are also available to office workers, construction and other trades, residents, teachers, students and others.
Anyone affected by the toxic air created by the events of 9/11, and not classified as a First Responder, even if your exposure was months later, is classified as a Survivor. Both First Responders and Survivors are potentially eligible for benefits.
One of the critical requirements for filing a claim with the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund (VCF) is providing definitive proof of presence in the exposure zone during the specified time period. This proof is necessary to establish that an individual was present at or near the World Trade Center site, the Pentagon, or the Shanksville, PA crash site on September 11, 2001, or during the subsequent cleanup and recovery efforts.You did not have to be part of the clean-up effort to be eligible. In this blog, we will explore what constitutes definitive proof of presence, the types of primary and secondary evidence accepted, and how the system works.
What is Proof of Presence?
Proof of presence is documentation or evidence that verifies an individual's location at or near the exposure zones during the eligible time frame. This proof is essential for demonstrating eligibility for compensation and benefits under the VCF. The VCF requires claimants to provide sufficient evidence to confirm their presence and exposure to the harmful conditions resulting from the 9/11 attacks.
Types of Evidence: Primary and Secondary Proof of Presence
Critical to a successful claim is providing the required proof of presence. Our experienced attorneys at Cannata, Hendele & Cannata have over twenty years devoted to filing claims on behalf of 9/11 victims.
The VCF categorizes proof of presence into two main types: primary and secondary evidence. Both types of evidence can be used to substantiate a claim, but primary evidence is typically more straightforward and conclusive.
Primary Proof of Presence
Primary evidence is considered the most direct and reliable form of proof. It includes documentation that clearly indicates the claimant's location in the exposure zone during the relevant period. Examples of primary evidence include:
- Employer Records: Official documents from an employer confirming the claimant's presence in the exposure zone. This can include employment records, work schedules, pay stubs, or a letter from the employer.
- School Records: Official records from a school indicating the claimant's attendance in the exposure zone. This can include attendance records, report cards, or a letter from the school.
- Residency Records: Documents that prove the claimant resided in the exposure zone. This can include lease agreements, utility bills, or mortgage statements showing the claimant's address during the relevant period.
- Official Government Records: Documents such as police reports, fire department records, or government-issued identification that confirm the claimant's presence in the exposure zone.
Secondary Proof of Presence
Secondary evidence may be used when primary evidence is not available or insufficient. It includes indirect or corroborative documentation that supports the claimant's presence in the exposure zone. Examples of secondary evidence include:
- Witness Statements: Affidavits or statements from individuals who can attest to the claimant's presence in the exposure zone. These statements should be detailed and provide specific information about the claimant's activities and location.
- Photographs: Photos that show the claimant in the exposure zone during the relevant period. These photos should be accompanied by a written explanation of the context and timeframe.
- Medical Records: Records from healthcare providers indicating treatment for conditions related to exposure in the relevant zone, especially if the treatment occurred shortly after the exposure period.
- Travel Records: Documents such as airline tickets, hotel receipts, or transportation records that corroborate the claimant's presence in the exposure zone.
How the System Works
The process of submitting proof of presence involves several steps. Claimants must gather and submit the necessary documentation as part of their VCF claim. Here is an overview of the process:
- Collect Documentation: Gather all relevant primary and secondary evidence that can substantiate your presence in the exposure zone. Ensure that the documents are clear, legible, and appropriately dated.
- Complete the Claim Form: Fill out the VCF claim form, providing detailed information about your presence in the exposure zone and the evidence you are submitting. Be thorough and precise in your descriptions.
- Submit Evidence: Attach the collected documentation to your claim form. Organize the evidence logically, and provide explanations where necessary to help the VCF reviewers understand the context and relevance of each document.
- Review and Verification: The VCF will review the submitted evidence to verify your presence in the exposure zone. This process may involve contacting your employer, school, or other sources to confirm the information provided.
- Follow-Up: Be prepared to provide additional information or clarification if requested by the VCF. Timely and accurate responses can help expedite the review process.
Conclusion: Ensuring Accurate and Comprehensive Proof of Presence
Providing definitive proof of presence is a crucial step in filing a successful VCF claim. By understanding the types of primary and secondary evidence required and following the correct procedures, claimants can ensure that their applications are complete and accurate. At Cannata, Hendele & Cannata, LLP, we are committed to assisting 9/11 survivors and responders in navigating the complexities of the VCF claims process.
If you have questions about providing proof of presence or need help with your VCF claim, please reach out to us. Our experienced team is here to provide the guidance and support you need to secure the compensation you deserve. Contact Cannata, Hendele & Cannata, LLP today for more information
Speak with a VCF Lawyer
Fill in the form and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.
